Snack Review
CHOCOLATE DOUBLE DECKER MOONPIE
I will freely admit -- it was reading David Magee's book that started me thinking about writing this review. The MoonPie is not a snack for which I automatically reach. (Look, we each have our own particular cravings, and for me, the MoonPie is a sporadic craving.)
I am far from being the MoonPie enthusiast that Magee is. I think the first time I can say for certain I was aware of the MoonPie was when it was mentioned in the song "Junk Food Junkie," although I have this vague feeling of awareness of the snack before then. Other snacks held me in their sugary thrall. As I recall, most of them were Hostess products. As a matter of fact, I am trying to remember when I first ate a MoonPie. I'm not completely certain, but I think it was sometime after I was out of college.
The MoonPie comes covered in three different flavors. Besides the original chocolate, there are also vanilla and banana covered MoonPies, plus the occasional seasonal coatings (I think strawberry and orange were two that Magee mentioned in his book). The chocolate is by far the most popular MoonPie flavor, though, and I decided to stick with tradition for this review. (Besides, do you really think I would choose any other flavor if the chocolate is available?)
For this review, I chose the Chocolate Double Decker MoonPie. (Okay, it was the first one I saw in the store.) The Double Decker MoonPie was first produced in the 1960s, as snack vending machines were becoming more popular. The original MoonPie would not fit correctly in the vending machines, and the larger Double Decker was created as something that would fit.
The Double Decker MoonPie is three graham cookies, sandwiching two layers of marshmallow filling. The resulting sandwich is then given one of the three flavored coatings, and as I mentioned, the MoonPie I chose has a chocolate coating.
From what I have read, the graham cookies come out of the oven crisp and crunchy. But once the cookies are joined with the marshmallow, the cookies begin to absorb moisture from the marshmallow, and they become softer. Now, this is not a bad thing; as it turns out, this is actually one of the reasons the MoonPie has a long shelf life. And the texture of the softer cookies compliments the marshmallow more.
The marshmallow is dense and chewy, not light and spongy. It makes eating a MoonPie akin to eating s'mores, except that you don’t have to worry about the whole process of roasting the marshmallows (or burning them, or burning your mouth while eating them). And if you really want to make eating a MoonPie like eating s'mores, you simply stick the MoonPie in the microwave for 5 to 15 seconds. (But please take it out of the wrapper first.)
The dominant flavor of the MoonPie by far is that of the cookie. There are occasional flashes of both the coating and the marshmallow over the tastebuds, but the graham cookie takes center stage on your tongue. As they absorb moisture from the marshmallow, they also become somewhat crumbly, but not until you start chewing on the MoonPie. The coating also helps maintain the pie's structural integrity to some degree, eventually yielding as you chew.
The traditional accompaniment for a MoonPie is Royal Crown Cola. Now, this did not come about as the result of some marketing agreement between the two manufacturers. Rather, it came about as a choice by consumers. Royal Crown came in larger bottles than other soft drinks, so people chose the larger soft drink to go with the larger snack. For this review, though, I decided to reverse tradition. Instead of Royal Crown, I chose Crown Royal whiskey to go with my MoonPie. The whiskey is smooth on the tongue, yet provides a stark contrast with the sweetness of the pie. It also serves as a way to cleanse the palate between bites.
Yes, this was my first MoonPie in quite some time. It won’t be my last -- for no other reason, I picked up a three-pack. And as I may have mentioned before, I'm thinking of playing around with some MoonPie recipes.
-jc-